Why Game Fishing Questions Our Ethics: A Personal Reflection

Reflections on Game Fishing and Compassion

Game fishing, a pursuit that captures the hearts of many, was entirely foreign to me until a recent trip to the Andamans. Growing up in a Jain family, my life was steeped in the principles of ahimsa, or non-violence, leading to my vegetarian upbringing and a natural aversion to activities involving harm to living beings. Yet, despite my trepidation, I found myself intrigued by the concept of game fishing—catching fish for fun with a catch-and-release clause that ostensibly promises a return to life in the ocean.

Just weeks ago, I experimented with game fishing during a staycation in Kerala, prompted by lingering curiosity but also an undercurrent of conflict. The guide handed me a rod, and with nervous excitement, I baited the hook and cast it into the sparkling waters of Vembanad Lake.

The thrill of feeling a tug at the end of the line quickly morphed into a deep unease when I reeled in a small fish, its scales shimmering in the sunlight. As I watched it gasp for air in sheer panic, my heart sank. The joy of the chase dissipated, replaced by a stark realization of the distress I was causing. Although the guide reassured me it had no visible wounds, I couldn't shake off the horror of that moment—the feeling of another creature struggling helplessly for breath. How could I possibly justify this, even with the intent to release?

The Ethics of Catch-and-Release Fishing

This personal encounter echoes broader ethical discussions surrounding recreational angling, like those highlighted by Max Elder in his analysis of the moral implications of fishing as merely a recreational activity. While catch-and-release practices are designed to minimize harm, they often inadequately address the stress and suffering inflicted on fish. The psychological impact of being caught and released has been a hot topic among fishing ethicists, raising questions about the validity of enjoying such an experience at the expense of another being's comfort and peace.

Furthermore, practices in India’s fishing industry illustrate that the issue of animal welfare extends beyond recreational pursuit. A recent investigation by Animal Equality revealed shocking cruelty within India’s fisheries, from overcrowded living conditions that cause immense suffering to brutal slaughter techniques. This reality underlines a striking inconsistency in how society treats aquatic lives, raising urgent ethical questions about our relationship with nature.

The Future of Ethical Fishing

As I reflect on my brief foray into game fishing, I’m reminded of the profound responsibility we bear towards all forms of life. If engaging in activities that evoke fear and stress, even momentarily, cannot be deemed a sport, what choices must we make to align our actions with compassion?

Thus, I find solace in advocating for kindness as I move forward. Choosing to protect marine life and spreading awareness about ethical fishing practices can transform our enjoyment of nature into something truly wholesome. In a world where every action counts, there remains a path toward revering and respecting life under water, inviting others to join me in this evolving journey of compassion.